|
Post by connie on Jan 30, 2013 12:51:11 GMT -5
Even the best histories miss some details. There's the old story of the blind men examining an elephant and reporting factually on what they observed. The person who felt the trunk has a totally different image to report than the one who felt the leg or the tail. All are accurate but incomplete.
Of course, well researched accounts also contain small errors.
Eye witnesses to intense times can't rely on total recall. Some things are indelibly etched on the memory. But there are often holes or gaps... things that can't be recalled. Here's where the collective memory comes in. Researchers count on being able to compare multiple accounts to find the accurate composite memory.
If you've uncovered a discrepancy, remember something differently, have a question, or can answer one about some detail in 106th history, here's a place you might record / discuss it. If you're adding a different perspective or correction to something written, please be sure to give the location of the other account.
|
|
|
Post by connie on Feb 2, 2013 11:42:13 GMT -5
I'll begin conversations with a small detail I can add: 590th Sv. Battery Location Dec. 16, 1944
Refinement to 590th Unit History The Cub of the Golden Lion Passes in Review p. 99
Richard Hartman, who did an excellent job writing 590th Unit History notes here: " It was also learned that Service Battery's positions had been hit during the shelling of St. Vith and that S/Sgt Stone, the mess sergeant had been killed."
This is close to accurate. St. Vith was being shelled around the time that the shelling of the 590th SV Battery began. And Sgt. Stone the mess Sgt., was indeed killed in the shelling of the Service Battery's position. But I can add some location refinement to this statement. I know the location of the Service Battery with absolute certainty. (In additional to other confirmations, my father was there and wrote this detail down in a post VE Day retrospective).They were billited some 5 miles east of St. Vith along the St. Vith- Schönberg Road in the village of Heuem, Belgium. (This village also was home to the headquarters of the division's combat engineers.)
|
|
|
Post by connie on May 24, 2013 20:07:47 GMT -5
|
|